Peters Cafe and Bakery in Cody

Fantastic. Great prices. Came here hoping to get breakfast for lunch for my 2 year old who kept asking for "Bacon and French toast please". They ended up making a custom order of a single piece of each for her! Not crowded and down to earth feel.

Great little place for brunch in Cody. Great home made food and good service. When you place your order at the counter you are given an object to mark your table. Ours was a green pull toy.

The staff are very friendly, and the food is made fresh with quality ingredients. This is the best place to get breakfast! Large portions and at a very affordable price. When we were there they had a person playing guitar that greeted you. We had a very nice time.

Nice place, different. Wasn't bad. Pretty good food

Ice cream wasn't bad, but not anything special. Customer service was mediocre, and the carpet is super stained and the place smells sort of musty from it. This may not seem like a big deal, but in my mind, a place that serves food should be a lot more sanitary and clean.

Don’t go there! We waited 45 minutes for sandwiches that were awful! I had eaten here several times years ago and thought i would take a walk down memory lane. The service was nonexistent. The two young people employed did not clear or wipe off tables. The restaurant is very shabby compared to what i remember it being. So sad this was kind of a staple for a quick sandwich or treat in the past.

Best biscuits and gravy I have EVER had in my life. Excellent home fries!

I came for breakfast. I wouldn’t say there was anything special about the breakfast. The service was excellent and efficient. The place seems a bit unclean. The ketchup bottles in the table were nasty. The salt and pepper shakers not clean either. If you want a classic greasy simple no frills American breakfast this is the place.

Great breakfast with quick service. There is a lady in the back that is a little grumpy. We enjoyed the food nice hardy. The service was very nice. The general aesthetic is interesting small town with a little country mixed with clutter.

ESPRESSO, ! And great food and service.Great mellow acoustic guitar live .... wow!

Nice little place! Solid food, good atmosphere, friendly staff and doesn't take itself too seriously.

Peter's is one of my favorite restaurants in town. Besides the friendly staff their food is just good! The soup is always so good too. I've never been dissatisfied at Peter's.

A little pricey... But a special treat for my kids when we're in town! Good memories!

Great food with many choices

Best grilled cheese and soup I've ever had. It might have had to do with me being hungry but I'd like to believe this would still win out in a head to head competition when I wasn't. Great food. Good service. Nice atmosphere. Cool downtown area.

Ice cream! Good tastes! Perfect

Love this little spot i try to get there anytime im in Cody.

I'd have given this place a 5 if the rating was based solely on the food. It was delicious, and the portion sizes are extremely generous for a great price. The people working behind the counter, though, were talking about the group of people I came in with, who were unhappy with their care-free service. They seemed to totally ignore everyone when behind the counter and didn't realize how loudly their voices carried through the rest of the diner. It's a shame, because with a few Clorox wipes, this place would definitely get a 5 star review.

First time eating here, was very disappointed. My bacon and eggs were fine, but the bread, pancakes, and hash browns were really gross. They were all soggy and tasted like they had bad milk involved. The bread was also squished, not sure if that was supposed to be on purpose or not...We had to ask for our coffee after waiting over a half hour. Not sure why but the cook was the only employee who looked over 18, which we found strange that only kids were working.

Party of 8, orders wrong, took forever to get the food. UN pleasant staff.

Friendly staff and the breakfast food was delicious!

Huckleberry ice cream so good!!!

Excellent fare, quality service, Stevie was most preshionable, such a delight, I had the popular breakfast while my wife enjoyed the eggs Benedict with what she says was the best Hollandaise sauce she's had. Definitely worth the stop!

I thought it was a little pricey for this type of place. Young personnel behind the counter were friendly. Traveling with therapy dog that was frowned upon even when she crawled under table away from customers.

If you need something to eat quick

Best scone I've tasted outside of Scotland! My kids had ice cream, fun local flavors. Not the cleanest or the most knowledgeable young staff but I would go back again.

Bagel Breakfast sandwiches were delicious. Lunch sandwiches are definitely the best. Big sandwiches, chips, strawberries, cookie... yummy!!

Well, food was okay but there was an employee, younger, that we saw sneeze into his hand then go about touching food. I did go up and ask him to wash his hands but he didn't. So then I went to the lady who was bring food from the kitchen and informed her. He did then at that time wash his hand. The young man did not appear sick but in this time of COVID, all people who work in the public should be educated on proper hand hygiene. I mean as kids we are taught to wash our hands. This is supposed to be common sense but it really isn't. Let's all do our part not only washing our hands but when you see an opportunity to educate, step up and help save lives.

Slow service; adequate food.

Good food and reasonable too

Good coffee nice environment. Good breakfast. Would go back nice staff!

Stopped in for breakfast while visiting town. Ordered 2 plates of eggs Benedict with home fries. The eggs Benedict came out and the hollandaise sauce was separating, the eggs appeared to have been microwaved (tasted like it too), and the English muffin on the bottom was very soggy and rubbery. like Other reviews made it seem like a great place to stop but DO NOT order eggs benedict. At least the deep fried frozen potatoes served with the meal were good!

Amazing ice cream. Everything tasted super good, and the staff was very pleasant to talk to.

Visited for breakfast on our way out of Cody. They were busy working on a large catering order but that didnt stop them from feeding us and about 20 more people. We also ordered a sandwich to take. When we stopped in the mountains to eat lunch we found they had packed us chips and the best brownies too! Amazing little restaurant with great food and even better people! Wish we didnt live 1500 miles away.

Great staff and atmosphere... Foods good too!

Absolutely AMAZING I live in Cody, and I just recently found went to Peter's for the first time and I was shocked it wasn't more popular and I have been back a few times since the food is fantastic and the Ice Cream is mouth wateringly good 11/10 would recommend.

I would have given this place a 5 star rating except for the totally blah, couldn't care less staff. Our burgers were very good...large beef patties with lots of toppings...great prices. The young girl who took our order could have cared less if we even existed. She was more interested in tasting the ice cream by the spoonfuls and being on her phone. The pastry cabinet windows, ice cream window and door needs to be cleaned but none of the staff was working on that. There are some many hand and finger prints on them you can barely see whats in the display. They were having fun amongst themselves though...laughing, etc...which was at least upbeat.

Probably has the best omelette in the town. It's a great place to stop in for a quick bite while strolling through historic downtown. Their sandwiches are also definitely worth a try. They also have great shakes!

Great breakfast and huge sandwiches for lunch at fair prices

The beginning of our visit was great .. then the food came out and it was wrong.. we have an allergy to pork , didnt ask for meat..gave it to us anyway .. we asked for am cheese in eggs , didnt have it made new and still brought out wrong order. The cook/manager was very rude and never once apologized.

We went there on a Sunday morning, the cafe was staffed by a few young boys. They struggled with the growing queue and had nobody experienced to support them. We waited in the line for 15 minutes only to learn that their credit card reader is broken, so we couldn't order anything as we only had a card on us. Is it that hard to put on a piece of paper on the door that says 'Cash/checque only, card reader out of order'? I think not.The only upside was the very nice man greeting everyone and playing the guitar.

Excellent little cafe. We had a delicious breakfast here on a recent Yellowstone trip. Came back in the evening for some of their ice cream and cinnamon rolls. Highly recommend. Thank you.

Great food, nice staff and the biggest variety of icecream in town

Great burgers, gluten free bread and wonderful ice cream.

Good food. Reasonable prices. Friendly staff. Would recommend to anyone visiting Cody.

The only thing I didn't like was that I feel it could be cleaned better. It wasn't filthy or anything, but for example the toys weren't clean. I think they should use different table markers or at least clean them.

Not very good. Poor service. After my wife order a sticky buns They set the bun back for her. Then they sold the bun to someone else.

Great tasting comfort food, staff and service are top notch. Loved the desserts🤗😍🦌🦊

Food is always good .

This is Cody's little hidden gem. Fresh, homemade buns for the burgers which are tasty. The homemade broccoli cheddar cheese soup is worth a visit just for it. Super friendly staff. There were a couple of unusual characteristics of Peter's Cafe that I found interesting. First, customers dish their own soup. That was different. And, I don't know if it is expected, but customers bus their own table. My wife and I observed other patrons cleaning up after themselves and putting their dirty dishes in a kitchen tote at the back of the restaurant. We followed their example and bussed our table. Again, I don't know if this is expected or just something that the patrons choose to do. Overall I would rate Peter's Cafe a 4.5.